Solution Providers Hub

HUB INTELLIGENCE

The Promotion Everyone Tried to Deliver

The Promotion Everyone Tried to Deliver

The Promotion Everyone Tried to Deliver

An ambitious consumer promotion can be difficult to supply even when everyone involved makes an effort. Once manufacturers and logistics partners have made their arrangements, who should be able to change the plan?

From Solution Providers Hub

Developed from discussions at Retail Summit Shaping Week

With research and interpretation support from 369DI

A retailer is planning a consumer promotion. For several days, it will advertise a special price on a product, hoping to sell considerably more of it than usual and attract extra shoppers into its stores. Making that offer work requires a manufacturer to produce more goods, logistics companies to transport the additional stock and the retailer’s warehouses to receive it. None of that is visible in the advertisement.

At Retail Summit Shaping Week, a participant from the logistics sector described how pressure to meet quarterly sales targets can lead to a large promotional order being agreed before its delivery requirements have been properly examined. He also spoke about a recurring problem in the everyday consumer goods market: manufacturers make room for extra production and logistics companies arrange weekend shifts, but the retailer’s warehouses may be unable to accept all the stock within the planned delivery period. Everyone has made an effort, yet the goods cannot all be received.

The manufacturer may be able to make the goods, and the transport company may be able to find the vehicles, but neither can increase how much stock the retailer’s warehouse can receive each day. In the same Shaping Week discussion, another participant raised a related risk: a promotion may already be advertised while the product is still missing from store shelves. The opportunity to attract shoppers is there, but the goods may not reach them when the offer begins.

Changing the dates is not always a simple way out. In a separate supply chain discussion, a food manufacturer explained that extra goods for a promotion may need to be produced shortly before the sale, so they have enough shelf life left when shoppers buy them. The manufacturer also has to store those goods until they can be delivered. When a retailer asks to postpone a launch or move deliveries, the request may arrive after production and storage arrangements have already been made.

By then, the people involved may have very different room to change their plans. The retailer might still be deciding the final quantity or launch date, while the manufacturer has arranged production and a logistics partner has reserved people and vehicles. A late change could improve the retailer’s chance of selling more, yet leave someone else with stock they cannot easily use or work that must be reorganised. Who should be able to change the promotion once those arrangements have been made, and who should carry the cost?

The retailer has a reasonable case for wanting that choice. A strong promotion may bring in shoppers who buy other products as well, so its benefit cannot always be judged by the margin on the advertised item alone. Paying for additional transport or a less convenient production schedule could be worthwhile if it helps generate enough extra business. A manufacturer knows what production can accommodate; a logistics provider knows what deliveries will cost. Neither can judge the full commercial value of the offer for the retailer.

That is a conversation worth having while the promotion can still be shaped. The retailer explains the sales opportunity it wants to capture, the manufacturer shows when decisions about production must be made, and the logistics partner sets out what can realistically be delivered. Just as importantly, the retailer’s own warehouse team can explain how much stock it can accept and on which days. Together, they may find that deliveries can be spread over a longer period without changing the offer shoppers see. They may choose a different volume or launch date, or conclude that the original plan is strong enough to justify the extra effort.

Talking earlier does not make their interests identical. The retailer may benefit from keeping the quantity open until close to launch, while the manufacturer needs to decide what to produce and the logistics provider must book people and vehicles. Even after everyone understands the constraints, there may be no easy agreement about unwanted stock, cancelled work or the extra cost of a late change. The disagreement is not simply about whether the promotion is possible. It is about how much freedom to change it each party should have, and who pays for that freedom.

Retail Summit 2027 will take this debate further in the Supply Chain Plenary panel, A Promotion Is Easy to Approve, Harder to Supply. A retailer may have sound reasons to change a consumer promotion after others have committed resources to it. A manufacturer or logistics partner may have equally sound reasons to resist. If changing the plan remains commercially attractive, who should decide whether to do it, and how should the costs and risks be shared?

RETAIL SUMMIT 2027

Continue the conversation

Continue the conversation

Retail Summit 2027 | 13–14 April 2027 | Warsaw

Retail Summit 2027 — coming soon